There is already plenty of information available on lead-free soldering materials and processes. For factories that need to develop a lead-free soldering process, selecting the right information and combining it effectively is critical. Developing a robust lead-free soldering line with high first-pass yield requires careful planning, committed execution, and strict process monitoring to ensure product quality and keep the process under control. These controls relate to many changes — materials, equipment, compatibility issues, contamination issues, statistical process control (SPC) procedures, and more.
Switching to lead-free soldering materials has a major impact on the soldering process, so every relevant aspect of the process must be optimized when developing a lead-free process. A five-step approach to developing lead-free soldering processes helps with both development and optimization.
1. Selecting the Right Materials and Methods
In lead-free soldering, choosing the soldering materials is the most challenging part. For lead-free processes, selecting lead-free solders, solder pastes, fluxes, and other materials is both the most critical and the most difficult decision. The types of components being soldered, the type of PCB, and their surface finishes must all be considered. The materials chosen should be proven in your own research, recommended by authoritative bodies or literature, or backed by prior experience. List these materials for testing in process trials to study them thoroughly and understand their impact on every aspect of the process.
The soldering method should be chosen for your actual situation — component types (surface-mount vs. through-hole), the PCB, and the number and layout of components on the board. Surface-mount components call for reflow soldering; through-hole components can use wave soldering, dip soldering, or spray soldering as appropriate. Wave soldering suits through-hole components across a whole (large) board; dip soldering suits whole (small) boards or local board areas; selective spray soldering suits individual or small numbers of through-hole components. Also note that lead-free soldering takes longer overall than leaded soldering and requires higher temperatures, because lead-free solders melt at higher temperatures and wet less readily.
Once the soldering method is chosen, the process type is set. Equipment, process control instruments, and inspection instruments must then be selected or upgraded to the process requirements. Like material selection, choosing soldering equipment and related instruments is equally critical.
2. Defining the Process Route and Conditions
With step one complete, welding process trials can be run on the selected soldering materials to define the process route and conditions. The listed materials need thorough testing to understand their characteristics and their impact on the process. The goal of this step is to develop lead-free soldered samples.
3. Developing a Robust Soldering Process
This step continues step two: analyzing the test data collected in the process trials, then improving materials and equipment or changing the process to arrive at a robust process under laboratory conditions. This step must also clarify what contamination lead-free alloy soldering may cause and how to prevent it, measure process capability (Cpk) for the various soldering characteristics, and compare against the original tin-lead process. This research yields inspection and test procedures for the soldering process, plus ways to handle process upsets.
4. Samples must also undergo reliability testing to verify that product quality meets requirements. If it does not, find the cause and fix it until it does. Once the reliability of the soldered product meets requirements, development of the lead-free soldering process is a success and the process is ready for volume production.
With everything ready, production can move from samples to industrial-scale manufacturing. Process monitoring must continue to keep the process under control.
5. Controlling and Improving the Process
A lead-free soldering process is a constantly moving target. Factories must stay alert to any problems that could let the process drift out of control, and keep improving it so product quality and first-pass yield keep rising. For any lead-free soldering process, better soldering materials and updated equipment both improve soldering performance.