General Steps for Selecting a Spot Welding Process
The process is usually selected based on the workpiece material and thickness, referring to the welding condition tables for that material. First, determine the electrode tip shape and size. Then make a preliminary selection of electrode force and weld time, and adjust the welding current, welding test coupons at different currents. Once inspection confirms the nugget diameter meets the requirements, adjust the electrode force, weld time, and current within an appropriate range, and weld and inspect test coupons until the weld quality fully meets the technical specifications.
What Are the Marks of a Quality Spot Weld?
The most common way to inspect a test coupon is the peel test: one piece of the torn coupon shows a round hole, and the other shows a round button. With thick plate or hardened materials, the hole and button sometimes cannot be torn out, but the nugget diameter can be judged from the sheared fracture surface. When necessary, low-magnification measurement, tensile testing, and X-ray inspection are also performed to evaluate the fusion rate, shear strength, and the presence of shrinkage cavities, cracks, and other defects.
How Does the Nugget Form When Welding Different Thicknesses or Different Materials?
When spot welding workpieces of unequal thickness or different materials, the nugget will not be symmetrical about the interface, but will shift toward the thicker side or the side with poorer electrical and thermal conductivity. This shift reduces the penetration rate in the thin part or the part with good conductivity, lowering weld strength. Nugget shift is caused by the different heat generation and heat dissipation conditions of the two workpieces. When thicknesses differ, the thicker side has higher resistance and the interface is farther from the electrode, so it generates more heat and dissipates less, causing the nugget to shift toward the thicker part. When materials differ, the material with poor conductivity generates heat easily but dissipates it with difficulty, so the nugget shifts toward that material, as shown in the figure on the right.
Principles for Correcting Nugget Shift:
Increase heat generation and reduce heat dissipation in the thin sheet or the workpiece with good electrical and thermal conductivity. Common methods for correcting nugget shift:
1. Use a "hard" schedule: this increases the influence of contact-resistance heat generation between the workpieces and reduces the influence of electrode heat dissipation. A good example is the capacitor-discharge welder, which uses high current and short weld time to weld workpieces with a very large thickness ratio.
2. Use electrodes with different contact face diameters: use a smaller diameter on the thin part or the side with good conductivity, to increase current density on that side and reduce the effect of electrode heat dissipation.
3. Use different electrode materials: use a copper alloy with poorer thermal conductivity on the thin part or the side with good conductivity, to reduce heat loss on that side.
4. Use process shims: place a shim made of a metal with poor thermal conductivity (0.2–0.3 mm thick) on the thin part or the side with good conductivity, to reduce heat dissipation on that side.
Characteristics of the Projection Welding Process
Projection welding is a variation of spot welding: projections are usually embossed on one of the two sheets, and then welded. Because the current is concentrated, it overcomes the nugget-shift drawback of spot welding, and the thickness ratio in projection welding can reach 6:1. During projection welding, the electrodes must follow down rapidly as the projections collapse; otherwise expulsion will occur due to loss of pressure. A larger electrode force should therefore be used. To prevent the projections from shifting, a smaller welding current should be used.
Projection Welding Process Parameters
Electrode force:
The electrode force in projection welding depends on the properties of the metal being welded, the size of the projections, and the number of projections welded at one time. The electrode force must be sufficient to fully collapse the projections when they reach welding temperature and to bring the two workpieces into intimate contact. Excessive electrode force will collapse the projections prematurely, defeating their purpose, and will reduce joint strength as current density falls. Too little force will cause severe expulsion. The follow-up performance of a projection welder should therefore be as high as possible; the main ways to improve follow-up are to reduce the mass of the moving parts of the pressure system and to use rolling friction in the guiding parts.
Weld time
For a given workpiece material and thickness, the weld time is determined by the welding current and the stiffness of the projections. When projection welding low-carbon and low-alloy steels, weld time is secondary compared with electrode force and welding current. After suitable electrode force and welding current are determined, the weld time is adjusted to obtain satisfactory welds. To shorten the weld time, the welding current must be increased accordingly, but an excessive increase may cause overheating and expulsion. Projection welding time is generally longer than spot welding time, while the current is smaller. Multi-spot projection welding takes slightly longer than single-spot projection welding, to compensate for uneven heating at each spot caused by inconsistent projection heights.
Welding current
The current required per weld in projection welding is smaller than for the same weld in spot welding. However, the current must be able to melt the projections before they are fully collapsed. The recommended current is the maximum current that, at a suitable electrode force, does not squeeze out excessive metal. For a given projection size, the amount of metal squeezed out increases with current. Using an upslope modulated current can reduce metal expulsion. As with spot welding, the properties and thickness of the metal being welded remain the primary basis for selecting the welding current.
In multi-spot projection welding, the total welding current is approximately the current required per projection multiplied by the number of projections. However, considering projection tolerances, workpiece shape, and the impedance of the welder's secondary circuit, some adjustment may be necessary.
Projection Position
In projection welding, heat balance between the two sheets must also be maintained; otherwise the projections will melt before the flat sheet reaches welding temperature. When welding dissimilar metals, the projections should be embossed on the workpiece with the higher resistivity. But when it is difficult to emboss projections on thick plate, they may be embossed on the thin sheet. Electrodes also affect the heat balance between the two workpieces. When welding thin sheet below 0.5 mm, tungsten–copper sintered material or tungsten electrode inserts are commonly used on the flat-sheet side to reduce heat dissipation there.